So, you’re thinking about getting a new multi-tool, but you’re stuck on which one is right for you. Don’t fret—I’m here to help break it down.

Today, we’re diving into the heart of every multi-tool: the pliers. Not all plier heads are created equal, and picking the wrong one could leave you frustrated.

Let’s get it right the first time.

Not All Pliers Are Built the Same

First off, bigger isn’t always better. Sure, that chunky pair of pliers on your shiny new multi-tool looks like it could wrestle a bear. But do you really need to wrestle a bear?

Think of it this way: the classic Leatherman PST wasn’t designed to replace your entire toolbox. Instead, it excelled as a reliable pair of needle-nose pliers with a little extra functionality. Its versatility didn’t sacrifice its usability.

The lesson? The more functions you cram into one tool, the more likely you are to lose efficiency in key areas. A giant plier head might handle tough, high-torque tasks, but when it comes to tight, tricky spots, it could fall short.

Pro Tip: Assess your needs first. Are you dealing with heavy-duty tasks or more delicate, precise work? Knowing this will steer you to the right choice.

When Bigger Is Better (and When It Isn’t)

There are situations where you’ll want a beefy pair of pliers. If you’re dealing with serious torque or heavy-duty tasks, larger models like the Leatherman Super Tool 300 or Surge won’t disappoint. These bad boys even feature hard wire cutters at the back, perfect for cutting through thicker materials.

But, keep one thing in mind—even the larger multi-tool pliers are hybrids. This means they can’t always match the precision and maneuverability of smaller, more nimble pliers. For instance, you shouldn’t expect them to excel at fine tasks like jewelry repairs or electrical wiring in tight corners.

Ask Yourself: Do I want my multi-tool to be my workhorse, or do I need something that’s a little more precise? The answer will guide your decision.

The Perils of Being Too Versatile

Some multi-tools try too hard to be everything at once, which isn’t always a good thing. Take the Spirit X pliers, for example. They’re built tough as nails, no doubt about it. But if you’re hoping they’ll function like true needle-nose pliers, you’ll be left disappointed. The design is simply too wide for delicate, precise tasks.

This is a common pitfall for tools striving to be “all-in-one” solutions. Sometimes, in trying to cover every possible need, they end up sacrificing the very qualities that make them exceptional for specific jobs.

Tip for Buyers: Always prioritize your primary use case. If precision and grip are essential, opt for a multi-tool designed with needle-nose functionality in mind. Otherwise, you might find yourself compromising too much.

Small Pliers Big Problems

Another common misconception is that pliers of the same shape will always perform the same. That couldn’t be further from the truth. Mini pliers are simply not built for heavy-duty tasks.

Take the Leatherman Juice, for instance. People often assume its pliers can handle everything its bigger counterparts can. But that’s just not the case. The smaller design limits its torque and strength, making it insufficient for demanding tasks.

If You’re a Tradesperson: You know the importance of having the right tool for the job. For rugged use, consider heavy-duty options like the Super Tool 300. You’ll thank yourself later when you’re not stuck struggling with a tool that’s too small for the task.

Forged vs Cast Why Strength Matters

Here’s a critical question that doesn’t get enough attention in multi-tool discussions—is your tool forged or cast? The difference is significant. Cast pliers, commonly found in multi-tools, are molded from molten material and can break under extreme stress. On the other hand, forged pliers, like those made by Knipex, are crafted through a heating and hammering process, giving them superior durability.

For example, forged pliers are strong enough to withstand a surprising amount of weight—even if you stand on them! Cast pliers, not so much.

Reality Check: Don’t expect your multi-tool to replace dedicated, heavy-duty tools like full-sized wrenches or bolt cutters. Multi-tools are lifesavers for daily tasks, but their limitations become apparent when put head-to-head with specialized tools.

Be Realistic About What Multi-Tools Can Do

At the end of the day, a multi-tool is a jack-of-all-trades but a master of none. If you expect it to outperform dedicated tools, you’ll be setting yourself up for disappointment. Always remember that multi-tools are designed for convenience and versatility, not for replacing your entire toolbox.

Why I Carry a Pliers Wrench: Sometimes, there’s a job that no multi-tool can efficiently handle. When heavy strain or torque is involved, I carry a dedicated pliers wrench instead of relying on my multi-tool alone.

Which Multi-Tool Should You Buy for Pliers?

Now, for the big question: Which multi-tool is the best for pliers? This is where your specific needs come into play. There’s no universal answer, but here are some top recommendations based on various use cases:

1. Gerber Dual Force
   • The standout choice for pliers enthusiasts. Made of forged steel plates and featuring a unique slip joint mechanism, no other multi-tool currently matches its capabilities. Looking for rugged power? This is it.
2. Leatherman Surge
   • Built like a tank, it’s a great option for those needing durable, heavy-duty pliers.
3. Leatherman Super Tool 300
   • Known for its reliability, this tool features beefy pliers ideal for tradespeople and rugged tasks.
4. Gerber Center Drive
   • Perfect for those who value efficiency, offering one-handed operation and great overall usability.

Honorable Mention: Unfortunately, the Leatherman Crunch is no longer available (RIP). If you manage to find one, hold onto it like a treasure.

Choose Wisely

Buying a multi-tool doesn’t have to be overwhelming. By thinking carefully about your specific needs, you’ll avoid wasting time, money, and energy on a tool that doesn’t fit the bill.

When it comes to pliers, specialization matters. There’s no one-size-fits-all option that will check every box. Be realistic about what you need from your multi-tool and choose accordingly.

Remember: Tools like the Gerber Dual Force, Leatherman Surge, and Super Tool 300 can enhance your gear setup significantly. However, they won’t replace a full set of properly-forged tools. But as convenient problem-solvers on the go, they’re hard to beat.